Good Governance Necessary for Restoring Public Trust in Bangladesh’s Banks

Download Presentation

The total volume of Non-Performing Loans (NPLs) has more than tripled in the last decade, skyrocketing from BDT 427.25 billion in Q4FY12 to an alarming BDT 1456.33 billion in Q2FY24. The Bangladesh Bank’s Financial Stability Report 2022 paints a stark picture, revealing that as of December 2022, the total gross NPLs stood at a staggering BDT 1,206.49 billion. This report also brings to light BDT 444.93 billion in outstanding written-off loans and BDT 2,127.8 billion in outstanding rescheduled loans. These figures cumulatively amount to a colossal BDT 3,779.22 billion (BDT 3,77,922 crore) worth of NPLs. The situation is further exacerbated by the 72,543 pending cases in the Money Loan Courts, with an outstanding amount of BDT 1,782.77 billion (BDT 1,78,277 crore).  The surge in NPLs demands immediate attention and a comprehensive strategy encompassing loan risk assessment practices, strengthening credit recovery mechanisms, and promoting a culture of responsible borrowing.

In this context, the Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD) organised a dialogue titled ‘What Lies Ahead for the Banking Sector in Bangladesh?’ on Thursday, 23 May 2024.

Professor Mustafizur Rahman, Distinguished Fellow, CPD, Chaired the session and remarked, ‘The banking sector of Bangladesh has grown in terms of the number of institutions, types of financing instruments, and asset volumes. However, it faces significant challenges due to malpractices, scams, corruption, and heists.’ Professor Mustafizur Rahman added that ‘there is a tendency for privatisation of profits and nationalisation of losses, which we must avoid’.

In her keynote presentation, Dr Fahmida Khatun, Executive Director, CPD, underscored the necessity of implementing a comprehensive reform agenda, focusing on reducing NPLs and establishing good governance to address the banking sector’s challenges.

She highlighted that public trust in the banking sector has been eroded due to the continuous deterioration in its health and inadequate measures by policymakers. Sporadic measures have failed because the nature and depth of the problem require comprehensive due diligence and structural reforms. Since reforms will face resistance from vested interest groups, they must be backed by political will.

Dr Khatun recommended that bank mergers should only proceed after a proper audit of weak banks to determine their real balance sheets. She also suggested that board members of weak banks should not sit on the boards of strong banks after mergers.

‘The Government should not inject capital into the proposed public Asset Management Company (AMC) to buy NPLs, as the Government already has supported weak banks using taxpayers’ money’, urged the Executive Director. The government should clearly define the AMC’s mandate, operation, management, and governance.

Moreover, internationally reputed and experienced private AMCs should be invited to resolve the NPL problem. The preconditions for setting up an AMC, such as good governance, transparency, and accountability, must be met to encourage such companies.

Dr Khatun stressed the importance of maintaining data integrity and ensuring timely access to information. She advocated for regular, publicly available reports on banks and financial institutions. Commercial banks must adhere to timely mandatory disclosures under BASEL III and classify loans according to international standards. Implementing a comprehensive risk management policy to identify and prevent malpractices is crucial.

‘A goal-specific, time-bound, inclusive, transparent, unbiased and independent Citizen’s Commission on Banking should be set up to bring transparency to the prevailing situation, identify the root causes of the manifest problems, and suggest credible measures for improving the situation sustainably’ recommended Dr Khatun.

She also suggested that commercial banks need strengthening through depoliticised board appointments based on qualifications, strict enforcement of single borrower exposure limits, and adherence to the Central Bank’s credit risk guidelines. Bangladesh Bank’s independence and autonomy must be upheld. The recapitalisation of poorly governed banks with public money should be stopped, and an exit policy for troubled banks must be formulated.

‘The industrial development, successful growth of businesses, and expansion of the export sector would not have been possible without the commercial banks’ execution of short-term borrowing and long-term lending’, commented Barrister Anisul Islam Mahmud, MP, Hon’ble Deputy Leader of the Opposition, Bangladesh Parliament, while discussing the default of loans. He added that commercial banks took significant risks and significantly contributed to the Bangladesh economy.

Mr M A Mannan, MP, Chairman, Parliamentary Standing Committee on Ministry of Planning, highlighted, ‘Streamlining the process for bank mergers is crucial. Although discussions on this topic have been ongoing, recent efforts have hit a roadblock, suggesting inadequate preliminary research and a lack of clear direction. It is imperative that policymakers, including those in opposition parties, unite to facilitate reforms and prevent unnecessary obstacles’.

Commenting on the lack of good governance, Dr Salehuddin Ahmed, Former Governor of Bangladesh Bank, said, ‘It is uncommon worldwide for governments, business owners, and bank owners to independently own and operate banks. Diversifying ownership of each bank could lead to better governance.’

‘The government’s borrowing from the central bank and commercial banks, due to revenue shortages, is causing a liquidity crisis’, underscored the Former Chairman of the Association of Bankers, Bangladesh Limited (ABB), Mr Mohammed Nurul Amin. He added that although borrowing from the central bank has decreased, the government continues to borrow from commercial banks. Efforts should be made to minimise the impact of these fiscal measures on the money market and monetary policies.

Mr Syed Ishtiaque Reza, Journalist and Adjunct Professor at the Department of Journalism and Media Communication, Green University, emphasised that to ensure Bangladesh Bank’s autonomy, it must be freed from the decision-making authority of the Financial Institutions Division wing under the Ministry of Finance (MoF). He highlighted that this wing exerts administrative and political power over banks and the financial sector, and therefore, its decision-making power should be revoked to protect the central bank’s independence.

High-level policymakers, political leaders, banking sector experts, bank officials, academics, development practitioners, business leaders, civil society activists, international development partners and journalists were present at the dialogue, many of whom participated in the discussions.

Among them were — Mr Mahbubur Rahman, Chairman & CEO of ETBL Holdings Limited; Mr Mohammad Muslim Chowdhury, Former Comptroller and Auditor General of Bangladesh; Professor Dr Barkat-E-Khuda, Dr Muzzafar Ahmed-Chair Professor Bangladesh Institute of Bank Management; Mr A. Gafur, Director, Abdul Monem Economic Zone Ltd and Country Adviser, American Apparel and Footwear Association (AAFA); Dr Md Main Uddin, Professor and Former Chairman, Department of Banking and Insurance, University of Dhaka; Mr Siddiqur Rahman Choudhury, Former Secretary, Finance Division and Former Chairman, Agrani Bank; Mr Shabbir Ahmed, Deputy Managing Director

Al-Arafah Islami Bank PLC; Dr Zahed Ur Rahman, Teacher, Columnist; Mr Mohammad Fazlul Karim,

General Manager, Agrani Bank PLC; Mr Mohammad Habibur Rahman, Deputy Managing Director, Social Islami Bank; DH Choudhury, Former Banker and Independent Director of Bank Asia Ltd; Mr Md. Bahar Mahmud, EVP & Head of IRM, Standard Bank PLC; Mr Md. Zia Arfin, Senior Executive Vice President, Bank Asia PLC; Mr Mosharaf Hossain, Principal Officer, National Bank Limited; Mr Md. Ahsan Ullah, Consultant, SWIFT & Former Executive Director, Bangladesh Bank; Mr Md. Shoaib Choudhury, Former Vice President of DCCI and Dr Shahidul Islam, Professor, Department of Banking and Insurance, Dhaka University.

PRESS REPORTS

English (42)

  1. The Daily Star 1
  2. The Daily Star 2
  3. The Daily Star 3
  4. The Daily Star 4
  5. The Financial Express 1
  6. The Financial Express 2
  7. The Financial Express 3
  8. Dhaka Tribune 1
  9. Dhaka Tribune 2
  10. The Daily Sun 1
  11. The Daily Sun 2
  12. The Daily Sun 3
  13. The Daily Sun 4
  14. The Business Standard
  15. New Age 1
  16. New Age 2
  17. Observer 1
  18. Observer 2
  19. Observer 3
  20. The Business Post 1
  21. The Business Post 2
  22. The Business Post 3
  23. Bangladesh Post 1
  24. Bangladesh Post 2
  25. UNB
  26. BSS News
  27. New Nation 1
  28. New Nation 2
  29. Asian Age
  30. The Daily Messenger 1
  31. The Daily Messenger 2
  32. Bangladesh Today
  33. Our Time 1
  34. Our Time 2
  35. Daily Industry 1
  36. Daily Industry 2
  37. The Daily Post
  38. The Daily Earth
  39. The Business Eye 1
  40. The Business Eye 2
  41. The Muslim Times
  42. News Time Bangla

Bangla (70)

  1. Prothomalo 1
  2. Prothomalo 2
  3. Prothomalo 3
  4. Prothomalo 4
  5. Prothomalo 5
  6. Ittefaq 1
  7. Ittefaq 2
  8. Jugantor 1
  9. Jugantor 2
  10. Kaler Kantho 1
  11. Kaler Kantho 2
  12. Samakal 1
  13. Samakal 2
  14. Samakal 3
  15. Bonik Barta
  16. Janakantha
  17. Inqilab 1
  18. Inqilab 2
  19. Bhorer Kagoj 1
  20. Bhorer Kagoj 2
  21. Dhaka Times 1
  22. Dhaka Times 2
  23. Amader Somoy 1
  24. Amader Somoy 2
  25. Amader Notun Shomoy
  26. Bangladesh Pratidin 1
  27. Bangladesh Pratidin 2
  28. Nayadiganta 1
  29. Nayadiganta 2
  30. Arthosuchak
  31. Alokito Bangladesh
  32. Desh Rupantor
  33. Jaijaidin
  34. Sangbad
  35. Daily Sangram
  36. Amader Orthoneeti
  37. Amar Sangbad 1
  38. Amar Sangbad 2
  39. Shomoyer Alo
  40. Ajkaler khobor
  41. Manabzamin 1
  42. Manabzamin 2
  43. Manabzamin 3
  44. Kalbela 1
  45. Kalbela 2
  46. Kalbela 3
  47. Amader Barta 1
  48. Amader Barta 2
  49. Amader Barta 3
  50. Khaborer Kagoj
  51. Protidiner Sangbad 1
  52. Protidiner Sangbad 2
  53. Swadesh Pratidin
  54. Sharebiz 1
  55. Sharebiz 2
  56. Manob Kantha
  57. Bhorer Darpan 1
  58. Bhorer Darpan 2
  59. Ajker Patrika
  60. Khola Kagoj
  61. Bangladesher Alo
  62. Shokaler Somoy
  63. Bangladesh Bulletin
  64. Dainik Bangla
  65. Ajker Darpan
  66. Sabuj Bangla
  67. Dainik Karatoa
  68. Ajkaler Khabor
  69. Protidiner Bangladesh 1
  70. Protidiner Bangladesh 2
  71. Protidiner Bangladesh 3

Online (70)

  1. The Daily Star (Bangla)
  2. Prothomalo (English) 1
  3. Prothomalo (English) 2
  4. The Daily Sun (Bangla)
  5. Observer (Bangla)
  6. UNB (Bangla)
  7. Bangla News 24
  8. BD News 24
  9. Jagonews 24
  10. Bangla Tribune 1
  11. Bangla Tribune 2
  12. Corporate Sangbad
  13. Barta 24
  14. Rising BD
  15. Zoombangla
  16. Daily Mukta Bangla
  17. News Bangla 24
  18. Vorer Pata
  19. Dhaka Mail
  20. Economi Post.Com
  21. News for Justice
  22. Suprobhat
  23. Dainik Shorobor
  24. Az News BD
  25. Outlook Bangla 1
  26. Outlook Bangla 2
  27. Dainik Ajker Bani
  28. Dhaka Press 1
  29. Dhaka Press 2
  30. Dhaka Prokash 24
  31. Gramnagar Barta
  32. News Now 24
  33. Bayanno
  34. Business Insights 24
  35. Somoy Journal
  36. Songbad Prokash
  37. Amader Brahmanbaria
  38. Bangladesher Kotha
  39. Voa Bangla
  40. Bangi News
  41. Khobor 71
  42. Uttaradhikar 71 News
  43. Desh Bangla Bd 24
  44. Digital Somoy
  45. Just News BD
  46. News Zone BD
  47. Orthosongbad
  48. Priyo 1
  49. Priyo 2
  50. Sangbad Sangjog
  51. Sara Bangla
  52. Share Bazar News
  53. Sun BD 24
  54. Business Journal 24
  55. Somoyer Khobor
  56. Ajkaler Kontho
  57. Passenger Voice
  58. Brittanto 24
  59. Channels
  60. Nayashatabdi
  61. Business Bangladesh
  62. Business Insider
  63. Khobor Sangjog
  64. Udyog News
  65. News Post BD
  66. Uddokta Bangladesh
  67. BD Sangbad
  68. Padma Times
  69. Rajshahi Sangbad